Ramos’ cats may not have nine lives, but Ramos’ sidewalk animal displays have survived decades of humane concern
NEW YORK, N.Y.––Even as animal advocates celebrated the October 22, 2026 vote of the New York City Council to ban horse-drawn carriages from the city, effective in June 2028, another longtime vexation reappeared, the scope of his animal use perhaps diminished, but still perplexingly immune to effective intervention by law enforcement.
“Joseph Ramos, who goes by Noah Live Love Boat, exploits various animals for years to get money from the public, displaying them on a small table at different spots in Manhattan, including dangerous subway platforms and in extreme weather,” emailed New York City resident Carrie Rosenblatt to ANIMALS 24-7.
“I saw him again this week”
“I saw him again this week,” Rosenblatt said, “going into the East 180th Street subway at about 2:40 pm with a dog, a frightened cat, and only one dove,” down from many Ramos has displayed in the past.
“He’s had cockatiels, conures, doves, and parakeets on the same table as cats,” Rosenblatt continued, sending photos of some of Ramos’ sidewalk exhibits.
“The black cat,” shown in two of Rosenblatt’s photos, “is old and sick.”
Subsequent to Rosenblatt taking the photo, she wrote, the Bronx-based organization Little Wanderers Cat Rescue “spoke to him and rescued her and another cat from him; they said that the birds and other animals needed rescue too.
“A rabbit died, guinea pigs are no more seen, and what became of all the birds?” Rosenblatt asked.
“He was seen feeding the cat birdseed!” Rosenblatt alleged, noting that “Even birds can’t survive on seed alone.”
Long-running controversy
Ramos, 79, also known as Joseph Noah, Joseph Noal and Joseph Noel, has apparently staged his New York City sidewalk animal exhibits at least since 2002, prompting complaints to the New York City-based American SPCA, other local animal advocacy groups, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), and New York City media at least since 2012.
ANIMALS 24-7 in 2017 and 2021 published previous exposés of Ramos’ activities and the failures of effective response by the ASPCA, New York City Public Health Department, and other agencies with relevant jurisdiction: see Panhandlers & street corner animal exhibitors: who is who? and Suspected drugged animals again displayed on New York City streets.
While Ramos by himself, like the long-running New York City horse-drawn carriage controversy, is not inherently an issue of national humane concern, what goes on in the nation’s biggest city tends to set examples, standards, and precedents for the rest of the U.S., and often the rest of the world.
Exhibitors, beggars, & homeless
Ramos represents multiple here-and-now dimensions of an ancient and ubiquitous problem: how to untangle and effectively regulate the distinctions among professional animal exhibitors, beggars using and misusing animals, and homeless people who keep companion animals, while at least nominally trying to re-establish themselves in normal, settled life.
These issues appear to have perplexed municipal governments for as long as cities have existed.
Further, the issues surrounding Ramos-Noal/Noah, complicated as they are, are simple compared to similar issues percolating in parts of the developing world.
There, the problems associated with street corner animal acts and panhandlers are compounded by mahouts who lead elephants into town, seeking either work or alms; snake charmers who may release snakes into homes in order to be hired to remove them; traveling dancing bear acts (now illegal in most nations); and pickpockets who work with trained monkeys.
Exploiting the intersections as well as the animals
The focal problems throughout the world, and throughout history, are cultural conflicts between concern for animal welfare and public safety, on the one hand, and sympathy for human underdogs and the civil rights of all citizens on the other.
Ramos has for almost a quarter of a century exploited the intersections of these concerns at some of the busiest traffic intersections in the world.
In New York City, as throughout the U.S., the right to keep animals and use then for economic purposes is constitutionally protected, albeit subject to “reasonable regulation” according to a long tradition of jurisprudence.
The U.S. Supreme Court has also accepted begging as constitutionally protected free speech.
Is Ramos an exhibitor?
Thus, if a panhandler keeps and uses animals, within the same constraints that apply to any other animal keeper, the panhandler has every legal right to do so.
But if the person keeping and using animals is an animal exhibitor, that person must possess local and perhaps also state and federal permits, depending on whether the animals involved are federally regulated species, covered by the Endangered Species Act, the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, or (rarely) the Marine Mammal Protection Act.
Even animals normally kept as pets, such as dogs, cats, rodents, and parrots, if used in public performances, tend to come under multiple levels of regulation meant to protect public health and safety.
Former addict
Ramos-Noal/Noah initially became notorious for displaying an altar-like menagerie mingling living, plush toy, and wooden animals at locations mostly on Lexington Avenue between 56th and 60th streets, and around Grand Central Terminal.
There he was cited by police at least once for “aggressive panhandling.”
“People love what I do,” Ramos-Noal/Noah told Kate Briquelet of Modal Trigger in June 2012. “I’m paying my bills the honorable way — out here with my own talent,” at that time purportedly collecting $40 to $50 an hour.
Ramos-Noal/Noah “said he had been addicted to alcohol and crack cocaine for more than 16 years before finding God — and the idea for his own version of Noah’s ark,” Briquelet wrote. “Ramos said he lives alone with the pets in his West Farms, Bronx, apartment. He started out panhandling with a poodle and a cat before using his funds to buy more pets for his sidewalk display.”
Ramos’ current address appears to be directly across the street from the Bronx Zoo.
Drugged animals?
The alleged humane issues involving Ramos’ sidewalk animal exhibits fall into two basic categories: subjecting small, sensitive species to the noise, car exhaust, and at times adverse weather encountered on New York City street corners, and the methods Ramos uses to keep the animals confined and/or immobilized in his displays.
Ramos has long denied drugging his animals.
The ASPCA, which in the past has vetted and sterilized some of the animals, claimed repeatedly between 2010 and 2017 to have found no evidence of sedation.
Critical observers, however, have often observed Ramos’ animals in a semi-paralytic state suggestive of drugging, including perhaps with ketamine, or with homebrewed derivatives of the Central and South American curare plant, long used by voodoo practitioners to induce a similar semi-paralytic state in both animals and humans.
“Induced tonic immobility”?
Another explanation sometimes offered for the motionless behavior of some of the animals may be a phenomenon called “induced tonic immobility.”
Explained Daniel Enger in the March 2014 edition of Popular Science, “Laboratory studies of “animal hypnosis” were fairly common in the 1970s and the 1980s.
“One paper defined its subject as ‘a state of prolonged, reversible immobility which is brought about by different types of sensory stimulation and is characterized by passivity and lack of responsiveness.’
“This is not so much a case of animals being hypnotized as playing possum,” Engber wrote. “Going limp while under threat makes predators lose interest and move on to other prey.”
Induced tonic immobility is known to occur with a variety of animals including rabbits, guinea pigs, chickens, ducks, and numerous cold-blooded species.
Waiting until either Ramos or the animals die
However, regardless of how Ramos achieves immobility among his animals, and as much concern as the sedation issue raises, sedating animals for any purpose is not illegal if the animals are otherwise healthy and the sedative is something that has been legally acquired and used.
Further, animals may not be impounded to test for sedation without the impounding agency first obtaining a search-and-seizure warrant, which requires some evidence of a crime having been committed.
Currently, the humane law enforcement response to Ramos appears to be simply waiting until either he drops dead, or what remains of his menagerie does, whichever comes first.
Please donate to help our work:
www.animals24-7.org/donate/
Discover more from Animals 24-7
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.














Thank you Merritt and Beth, for exposing this gruesome abuser who needs to be shut down.
That he is exploiting animals, misusing, is obvious. Very likely drugging them.
He needs to be prevented from owning any animals. Does he even have permits? Vet receipts? Have officers even investigated his home, animal feeding and bedding?
While he lives his animals suffer.
It’s very concerning whenever animals of any species are exploited, on the streeets, for money that may or may not go wholly or at least partially to their care. As your article states, it is very difficult to determine what, if any, crime(s) are being committed in this case.
Years ago, I witnessed a man who had apparently trained his cat as a “psychic.” The cat appeared to be healthy and alert, but she was dressed in clothing; I have never seen any reason for cats to wear clothes, and I was vaguely disturbed by this, though she did not appear to be abused in any way. I gave the man a donation which he was apparently surprised at the amount of; I hoped that at least part of it would go to the care of his cat, who was lovely. He gave me a laminated photo card with her picture and website, which does not exist now. This was on the boardwalk in Santa Monica, California.
Thanking you for your article. I do hope these animals are safe and given at least adequate care.
Agreeing with the former contributor, I, a California citizen, who had never heard of this person and his obvious exploitation of most ignorant persons’ understanding of animal welfare, is totally appalled at this story.
That there are so many rules and regulations in so many walks of life, and yet NONE is applicable to Mr. Ramos and his cruelty to animals is astounding.
I am aware of the many forms of such vile conduct in other countries, but this form of peverse animal mistreatment is new to me.
It’s appalling that he has been able to sustain this operation for so many years while these animals bear the consequences.
It came as a shock to read this article.
Living in NYC, I and millions of others could not avoid seeing this emotionally disturbed man engaged in his bizarre form of animal abuse. He was everywhere.
But I had not seen him for a very long time–probably close to 15 years–although there were reports of him. I had thought he was gone. But no, you point out, he is still here.
In the years he was everywhere, I spent an enormous amount of time and effort—contacting every agency that I thought would help–to try to stop his activities.
Memories come back.
Unnaturally still animals–not moving one inch–completely indifferent and unresponsive to the piercing sound of screaming fire engines and ambulances–
Cats–who appeared comatose–not moving while birds were on their back–
Hamsters and gerbils so still it was impossible to determine if they were actually alive–
Joseph Ramos–leaving all the animals–not one of them moving–as he knew they would not move–on the display table and on the street next to the table–on the south side of 86 Street–and crossing to the north side to go to his car–for at least a full 15 minutes–
His dog wandering off more than half a city block–without his being aware of it–until someone informed him–
One of my calls to the police department when I saw him on Lexington Avenue with all his animals–like the living dead–spread out on his display table and on the street. The police came, asked him for a permit–and when he could not produce one, told him to pack up–which he did, left him with all the animals………….and then drove off.
People looking at these displays–some at first struck with the garden-of-eden peace scene–
and then understanding what they were looking at–identified it as a display of drugged animals.
That is exactly what I saw.
The fact that this continues–like every other form of cruelty to animals that has continued for so long–in spite of decades of documentation of the cruelty–spells out where more effort should be focused–on enforcement and holding agencies and the heads of agencies that do not carry out enforcement of animal protection laws accountable for not doing their jobs.