
(Beth Clifton collage)
31 missing cockfighters becomes a presidential campaign issue in the Philippines
LEXINGTON, Kentucky; MANILA, Philippines––The U.S. Department of Justice on March 2, 2022 disclosed the names of four more alleged cockfighters against whom sealed federal indictments were issued on February 24, 2022 in London, Kentucky.
No further information, however, has been forthcoming about who was arrested and charged with what following a February 25, 2022 FBI raid on an alleged cockpit in Whitesburg, Kentucky.
Involving an estimated 100 federal agents, supported by an armored car and a helicopter, the Whitesburg raid is believed to have apprehended some of the previously indicted suspects, as well as others whose indictments have yet to be disclosed.
(See Feds indict 13 Kentucky cockfighters flushed out by SHARK; more busts likely and See also And right on cue, here come the parasites, by Steve Hindi.)


“The disappearance of 31 people is not normal”
Nine thousand miles away, Philippine senator and presidential candidate Panfilo Lacson ripped alleged police corruption and incompetence in connection with the unsolved disappearance of 31 cockfighters between April 28, 2021 and January 13, 2022.
“They should speed up the investigation because the disappearance of 31 people is not normal. If you cannot resolve any of the 31 cases, that says a lot about the capability of the Philippine National Police,” Lacson told a media conference in Daet, Camarines Norte.
(See FBI raids alleged Kentucky cockpit; 31 cockfighters “disappear” in Philippines.)


Cockfighting & corruption
Lacson sounded a bit like Showing Animals Respect & Kindness [SHARK] founder Steve Hindi.
Investigating cockfighting in Kentucky since 2019, backed by the Humane Farming Association, SHARK initially shared leads about cockfighting dates and venues with local sheriff’s departments.
Encountering indifference and even hostility from many Kentucky sheriff’s departments, SHARK turned to exposing allegedly corrupt sheriffs as well as cockfights and cockfighters, and took increasingly extensive evidence to the state and federal levels, helping to facilitate the recent indictments.
Despite the distance from Kentucky to the Philippines, there is a considerable two-way traffic in gamecocks among cockfighters in either location, and some Kentucky cockfighters have urged via social media that Hindi and others involved in exposing their activity should be made to “disappear” like the missing Filipinos.


(Facebook photo)
Four more names
Among the additional names of indicted alleged cockfighters disclosed by the Department of Justice on March 2, 2022 were Cruz Alejandro Mercado-Vazquez, 43, of Maysville, Kentucky; Walter H. Mitchell, 55, of Ewing, Kentucky; and Jerrard McVey, 47, and his wife Linda McVey, 42, of Carlisle, Kentucky.
Cruz Alejandro Mercado-Vazquez is facing “two counts of attempted bribery and one count of possessing animals for the purpose of having the animals participate in an animal fighting venture,” the U.S. Department of Justice said.
“The indictment alleges,” the U.S. Department of Justice summarized, “that, on two separate occasions, Mercado-Vaquez offered a bribe of more than $5,000 to the Mason County sheriff, to influence the sheriff in connection with a planned animal fighting venture. The indictment further alleges that Mercado-Vazquez knowingly bought, possessed, and trained roosters to participate in an animal fighting venture.”
Mitchell and the McVeys were charged “with conspiracy to knowingly sponsor and exhibit animals in an animal fighting venture, in connection with the Valley, a chicken pit on the border of Nicholas and Fleming counties,” the U.S. Department of Justice media release said.


(Facebook photo)
Spokespersons emphasize cruelty
Cockfighting has historically been prosecuted as much in connection with illegal gambling as for cruelty to gamefowl, but both Carlton S. Shier IV, U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Kentucky, and Jodi Cohen, the FBI special agent in charge of the federal cockfighting investigations, emphasized the cruelty aspects in their media statements.
“Animal fighting ventures are cruel and illegal,” said Shier. “We are committed to enforcing federal animal cruelty laws.”
Added Cohen, “The gruesome ritual of animal fighting simply has no place in a civilized society. Animal cruelty, however, is just one criminal aspect surrounding this barbaric activity,” Cohen continued. “Whether it is illegal gambling or the attempted corruption of our public officials, the criminal enterprise surrounding cockfighting operations will not be tolerated.”


(Facebook photo)
Facing up to five years in prison plus fines
Other agencies involved in the investigation include the U.S. Department of Agriculture, the Kentucky State Police, and the Indiana Gaming Commission, the latter for as yet undisclosed reasons believed to have to do with gamblers and gamecock breeders from Indiana attending Kentucky cockfights.
“Each defendant faces up to five years in prison and a maximum fine of $250,000,” the U.S. Department of Justice media release stipulated. “Mercado-Vasquez faces up to 10 years in prison and a maximum fine of $250,000 for the attempted bribery counts.”
Lexington Herald-Leader Bill Estep meanwhile called into question the law enforcement connections of three of the individuals whose indictments were announced earlier.


(Laurel County Sheriff’s Office)
Sheriffs deny employing indicted suspects
“Indictment documents said three of those charged had worked at times for sheriff’s offices in Clay and Laurel counties,” Estep wrote, “but the three most recent sheriffs in Clay County said the two residents named there,” Beachel Collett, 28, and Lester Collett, 25, “had not worked for them.
“Kevin Johnson, who was sheriff three terms in Clay County; his wife Angie Johnson, who succeeded him for a year, and current Sheriff Patrick Robinson said the Colletts had not worked for the sheriff’s office in their terms, dating back to 2007,” Estep reported.
“In Laurel County,” Estep continued, “a woman who worked as a court bailiff for the sheriff’s office,” Jacklyn R. Johnson, now federally indicted, “left the job after Kentucky State Police charged her last year in state court with promoting gambling in connection with a cockfighting operation.
Indicted alleged cockfighter Millard Oscar Hubbard, 72, however, is “a former teacher and transportation director for the Clay County school system,” Estep reported, who “pleaded guilty in 2005 to conspiring to distribute 300 pounds of marijuana and was sentenced to 32 months in prison.”


Online gambling on cockfights
Meanwhile back in the Philippines, Paolo Romero of the Philippine Star reported, Philippine senate president Vicente Sotto III told media that current Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte is awaiting a resolution from the senate committee on public order and dangerous drugs, and a recommendation from the Philippine Amusement & Gaming Corporation, before suspending the operating licenses of seven concessionaires offering online gambling on cockfights.
Running for vice president on the same ticket as presidential candidate Paniflo Lacson, Sotto has asked that online gambling on cockfights be suspended until the case of the 31 missing cockfighters is resolved.


Chief reminds cops of code of ethics
Continued Romero, “Former Philippine National Police chief Guillermo Eleazar, who is also running under the Lacson-Sotto ticket, reminded police officers of the code of ethics which prohibits them from engaging in gambling even if such games are legal.”
Current Philippine National Police chief General Dinardo Carlos on March 2, 2002 “vowed to impose a one-strike policy on police commanders whose subordinates are caught” gambling on cockfights.


“To ensure strict compliance,” Romero said, Carlos “ordered an inspection of cell phones and gadgets of police personnel and warned unit commanders that they will be relieved of their posts if found to be engaged” in online betting on cockfights.
I just can’t believe you people you all make me sick to my stomach you all are the parasites leave us cockfighters alone
We don’t bother you ass wipes we are trying to continue family tradition and our heritage’s
We build community we build economies
We do a lot of good and some place wouldn’t even exist if it wasn’t for our sport and that is what it is a sport like horse race you all need to learn and understand this sport you and no one else has any right to interfere in
You are all the parasites the bottom feeders
That cockfighting is in any way part of the authentic Appalachian tradition and heritage is among the biggest of many big lies told by cockfighters.
University of Kentucky historian Joseph R. Jones in “Out of Sight, Out of Mind: Recovering the History of Cockfighting in Kentucky,” published in the Winter 1997 editor of the Kentucky Review, https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/232574292.pdf, noted that “The excellent new Kentucky Encyclopedia (1992) does not even contain the word cockfighting in its survey of the sports of Kentuckians ancient and modern.”
This confirmed the complete absence of cockfighting from any mention in the works of Kentucky’s most eminent folklorist, James Taylor Adams (1892-1954). Adams spent most of his life in Big Laurel, Kentucky, almost within sight of the present location of the Pinemountain Game club.
In truth, cockfighting, extinct in Appalachia since frontier days, was brought back to the region during Prohibition, along with moonshining, rum-running, dogfighting, prostitution, and other gambling rackets, as money-making activities of the Ku Klux Klan, which was to the rural South as the Mafia was to Chicago, New York, and Boston.
Far from “building community and economies,” cockfighting, like other forms of organized crime, saps resources from communities and inhibits economic growth.
By way of comparison and contrast, when cockfighting began a comeback in Appalachia circa 90-100 years ago, the Green Mountains of Vermont were the poorest region of the U.S., with far less by way of natural resources and tillable farm land, worse transportation, and had just been devastated by the Flood of 1927, which destroyed almost every bridge and dam in the state. Vermont, however, resoundingly rejected Ku Klux Klan incursions, never culturally accepted cockfighting nor any other form of gambling, emphasized improving education as a state priority, and though still just as remote as Appalachia, with much longer and harsher winters, is today the most prosperous rural U.S. state.
Mr. sharks lucky to be alive keeps messing around down there he’s really gonna get hurt and people need to mind their own business that’s their livelihood down there you’re not hurting nobody you don’t like it don’t watch it don’t participate in it stay away from it and keep making up all these laws this country is going to crumble you get pretty desperate getting in our personal freedoms they have no right to us how we should be able to harvest our file Mr. shark was so worried about these birds why don’t they build pins for these birds and take care of them instead of euthanizing them and putting all that money in their pockets that are so worried about these animals they’re the ones it euthanize him and destroy them these people start waking up on his animal activist you’re nothing but disgusting people all they do is put the animals down and put the money in their pockets and all these stupid commercials on here that show these poor dolls out on chains and stuff it’s disgusting they want that donation sick and fill their pockets up they don’t care about them animals know that means of dollars of donations they have collected why haven’t they build shelters and took care of these animals that they care so much about and paid people to take care of them with all the money they’ve gotten in donations but no they put all that money in their pockets and the government needs to put a stop to that yes we do need a Humane Society for people that does not take care of their animals like not feeding him keep them in warm shelters I would have you shark guy Steve hIdi he is a joke Or whatever his last name is he’s pathetic
You guys leave them people alone in Kentucky mind your own damn business and shark all he’s doing is trying to get his pockets full they don’t care about them birds or he just take And euthanizes them
This commenter should be aware that it was the Kentucky legislature, as elected voice of the people, that has made cockfighting illegal in Kentucky since 1893; that Steve Hindi of Showing Animals Respect in Kindness is conducting investigations of cockfighting and police corruption in Kentucky in response to appeals from Kentuckians which have unfortunately gone ignored by the big national humane organizations, apparently because there is no money to be made from addressing an issue which mostly afflicts poor rural communities; that Hindi has never drawn a salary for his animal advocacy work, and has in fact financed much of it from his own success as a now retired manufacturer whose industrial products helped to employ 20,000 Kentuckians; and that Hindi has argued for years that the legal penalties for cockfighting should include obliging convicted cockfighters to pay for the lifelong sanctuary care of the birds confiscated. Cockfighters have lobbied long and hard against having their moral & ethical obligations toward their birds written into law.