• News home
  • About us
  • Our bios
  • Contact us
  • Cats
  • Disasters
  • Pit bull data
  • How to help us
  • Get alerts!

Animals 24-7

News on dogs, cats, horses, wildlife, zoonoses, & nature

  • USA
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa
  • The Americas
  • Europe
  • Obituaries
  • Please donate!
  • Coming Events

Montreal appeal of stay on pit bull ban is authorized to proceed

October 21, 2016 By Merritt Clifton

Quebec Court of Appeals building in Montreal.

Quebec Court of Appeals building in Montreal.

Hearing set for November 25,  2016

MONTREAL––Quebec Court of Appeal Judge Manon Savard on October 20,  2016 allowed the City of Montreal to appeal the October 5,  2016 suspension of the city pit bull ordinance by Superior Court Judge Louis Gouin.

Quebec Court of Appeals Judge Manon Savard.

Quebec Court of Appeals Judge Manon Savard.

Having already temporarily suspended enforcement of the ordinance on October 3,  2016,  the day it was to take effect,  Gouin two days later extended the suspension until such time as all litigation against the ordinance is heard and the ban is held to be legal under Quebec and Canadian law.

“Character required” to justify appeal

This could mean a delay of years while lower courts review the multiple cases filed against the Montreal ban by the Montreal SPCA and other pit bull advocates,  and the verdicts,  whichever way they go,  proceed through appeals.

Wrote Judge Savard,   “I think the situation has the character required to justify permission to appeal the order.”

Quebec flag pitBut stay remains in effect until hearing on appeal

However,  Judge Savard allowed the suspension of the ordinance to remain in effect pending a hearing of the appeal scheduled for November 25,  2016.

Immediately lifting the suspension,  Judge Savard said,  “is not necessary considering the early date of hearing.”

At the November 25,  2016 hearing,  a City of Montreal representative will be given half an hour to make a case as to why the suspension should be lifted,  after which the Montreal SPCA will be allowed to give a half an hour rebuttal.

Judge Louis Gouin

Judge Louis Gouin

Lower court judge wanted definition of “pit bull” weakened

Judge Gouin on October 3,  2016 all but ordered the Montreal city council to amend the definition of “pit bull” in the ordinance,  interpreting the term “pit bull” to be a “breed,”  the traits of which might be extinguished after a specific number of crosses with other breeds,  rather than a morphological type,  the dangerous characteristics of which might be intensified by out-crosses to enhance size,  strength,  and speed.

Denis Coderre unmuzzled.

Denis Coderre unmuzzled.

Mayor pursues appeal

Instead of yielding to Gouin,  Montreal mayor Denis Coderre on October 6,  2016 announced that his administration would pursue an immediate appeal.

“Prohibiting the acquisition of new pit bull-type dogs,  from the date of entry into force of the regulation,  we believe is a sensible solution to the problem of attacks and repeated bites,”  Coderre wrote,  in a statement published by ANIMALS 24-7 (in translation) as well as by other media.

“These requirements address a disproportionate number of attacks by this type of dog,”  Coderre said,  “and the much more serious injuries they can inflict.”  

Foreground: Montreal mayor Denis Coderre. Background: anti-pit bull ban demonstrators whose signs, overwhelmingly in English, suggested that they may have come from the U.S.

Foreground: Montreal mayor Denis Coderre. Background: anti-pit bull ban demonstrators.

(See Safety first! by Denis Coderre, Mayor of Montreal.)

“Elements remain suspended”

Explained Montreal Gazette reporter Rene Bruemmer,  “For now,  elements of the bylaw pertaining to pit bull-type dogs remain suspended.  That means the dogs can still be acquired and adopted,  and current owners do not have to buy a special $150 permit or muzzle them when outdoors.

“If the city wins its appeal,”  Bruemmer said,   “the suspension will be lifted and the pit bull ban will come into effect.  If the city does not win, the suspension will stay in place pending a court case on the legality of the new bylaw,  to be heard months from now.”

The Montreal SPCA brought in actress Pamela Anderson to help fight the Montreal pit bull ban.

The Montreal SPCA brought in actress Pamela Anderson to help fight the Montreal pit bull ban.

Pit bulls still up for adoption

Montreal SPCA representative Sophie Gaillard told Marie Christine Trottier of the Journal de Montreal that she was pleased the suspension would remain in effect at least until November 25,  2016,  as “It will allow us to continue to put pit bulls up for adoption.”

The flags are those of Montreal on the left, Canada on the right. (Beth Clifton photo)

The flags are those of Montreal on the left, Canada on the right.
(Beth Clifton photo)

Voting trends favor the ban

Judge Savard authorized the appeal by the City of Montreal to proceed one day after a Forum Research poll commissioned by the Montreal Gazette,  which editorially opposes the pit bull ban,  reported that support for the ban “has weakened significantly.”

The actual numbers suggest the appearance of weakened support would vanish if adjusted to reflect voting trends.

Summarized Gazette writer Bruemmer,  “The city is now divided over the question,  according to a survey of 808 people over the weekend of October 15-16,  2016.   Forty-nine per cent of respondents said they approve of Montreal’s ban on pit bull-type dogs,  while 44% are against it,  with 6% saying they have no opinion on the issue.

Marie-Claude Malboeuf (La Presse photo)

Marie-Claude Malboeuf
(La Presse photo)

La Presse survey found 70% support for ban

“That is a marked drop in support for the idea of banning pit bulls,”  Bruemmer said,  “compared to a CROP-La Presse survey taken in June 2016,   two weeks after 55-year-old Christiane Vadnais was fatally mauled by a neighbor’s dog in her backyard in Pointe-aux-Trembles,”  a Montreal borough.

The dog who killed Vadnais was a pit bull,  who had been registered as a boxer,  La Presse investigative reporter Marie-Claude Malboef discovered,  to avoid a borough-wide pit bull ban already in effect.

From "Liberty Leading the People," a painting by Eugène Delacroix commemorating the July Revolution of 1830, which toppled King Charles X of France.

From “Liberty Leading the People,” a painting by Eugène Delacroix commemorating the July Revolution of 1830, which toppled King Charles X of France.

The June poll,  recalled Bruemmer,  found 70% support for the pit bull ban.

English/French split

“Striking is the large disparity,”  acknowledged Bruemmer,  “that has emerged between the anglophone (English-speaking) and francophone (French-speaking response:  Only 36% of polled anglophones favor the ban,  while 50% of francophones are in favor.

“Those who classified their mother tongue as neither English nor French are 64% in favor of the ban,”  Bruemmer wrote.

(Beth Clifton collage)

(Beth Clifton collage)

Demographics

French-speaking people currently constitute 65% of the total population of Greater Montreal,  and about 80% of the total population of Quebec province.  English-speaking people are 12.6% of Greater Montreal,  but less than 10% of the total population of Quebec province.   People whose first language is neither French nor English are 20.4% of Greater Montreal,  but about 12% of the total population of Quebec province.

The raw data projects approximately the 49%-44% split in public opinion that Forum Research reported (actually 50%-44%).

(Beth Clifton collage)

(Beth Clifton collage)

Parents favor the ban

However,  Bruemmer added,  “Older residents,  parents of children,  the wealthy,  and the more highly educated are also more likely to favor the ban,”  as contrasted to those in the 18-to-34-year-old category,  only 27% of whom favored it.

Conversely,  Bruemmer acknowledged,  “Among those 35 and older,  approval rates hovered around 58%.”

The youngest age group polled are the Montreal residents least likely to vote or be registered to vote,  and include the student populations of the several Montreal universities,  many of whom are only transiently part of the community.  The median age of greater Montreal residents is about age 40,  but the median age of voters is 45+.

rp_PicsArt_1476251280827-29-247x300.jpg

Please help us continue speaking truth to power: 

http://www.animals24-7.org/donate/

Related Posts

  • Judge suspends Montreal pit bull ban enforcementJudge suspends Montreal pit bull ban enforcement
  • Montreal carriage horse trade ends,  after 354 yearsMontreal carriage horse trade ends, after 354 years
  • How the Pit Bull Federation of South Africa views GalunkerHow the Pit Bull Federation of South Africa views Galunker
  • Quebec Court of Appeals allows Montreal pit bull ban to take effectQuebec Court of Appeals allows Montreal pit bull ban to take effect
  • Enforcement of Montreal pit bull ban indefinitely delayedEnforcement of Montreal pit bull ban indefinitely delayed
  • Montreal bans pit bullsMontreal bans pit bulls

Share this:

  • Tweet

Related

Filed Under: Animal control, Animal organizations, Breeding, Canada, Dog attacks, Dogfighting, Dogs, Dogs & Cats, Feature Home Bottom, Laws & politics, Population control, Shelters, The Americas, USA, Uses of dogs Tagged With: Denis Coderre, Judge Louis Gouin, Judge Manon Savard, Merritt Clifton

Comments

  1. Mary Ann Redfern says

    October 21, 2016 at 8:03 am

    Excellent breakdown of the issue and stats. Thank you.

Quick links to coverage of dangerous dogs

FREE SUBSCRIPTION!!!

The Americas

  • Canada
  • Caribbean
  • Central America
  • Mexico
  • South America
  • Email alert list – Sign up today!
  • Our biographies
  • Memorials
  • Pit bull data
  • Black history & animals

©

Copyright 2014-2021

Animals 24-7 · All Rights Reserved · Admin

 

Loading Comments...