by Karen Davis, PhD, President of United Poultry Concerns
“Dear Animal Shelter, I see you have a rooster right now. I have a placement lined up for him and would like to pick him up Saturday.”
Animal Shelter: “Thanks for inquiring about the rooster. It’s great to know there is a potential placement for him. We’ve actually just learned of a new development on the state level that will impact this guy’s availability.”
This is the gist of an email exchange in North Carolina in May. The rooster whose prospects were so promising, instead of going to a sanctuary, is now dead, because the shelter killed him. Why?
No creature on earth more cursed
I will begin by saying that no creature on earth is more cursed than chickens are cursed by the human species. In the course of thousands of years, chickens have gone from the tropical forest to the factory farm, with few good stops in between. Because factory farming is so incorrigibly cruel, some people view the recent trend in backyard chicken-keeping as a humane alternative.
To the extent that backyard chickens awaken novices to the fact that chickens are lively, sociable individuals with intelligence and feelings, and insofar as zoning laws allowing the keeping of a few chickens mean more homes for sanctuaries and shelters to place abandoned birds in, backyard-chicken-keeping has benefitted chickens. Moreover, there is no question that a well-cared-for backyard chicken has a better life than a factory-farm chicken.
Backyard chicken-keeping fraught with problems
But those of us working in sanctuaries and shelters have also learned that backyard chicken-keeping is fraught with problems that link it to the industrial world of poultry and egg production.
Most animal advocates are aware by now that the global egg industry destroys billions of male chicks as soon as they hatch.
Countless more chickens, turkeys, quails, ducks and other birds born in hatcheries are treated the same. Upon breaking out of their shells in the mechanical incubators, instead of being sheltered by a mother hen’s wings and protected by a vigilant rooster, the newborn chicks are ground up alive, electrocuted, or thrown into plastic-lined trashcans, sometimes being gassed with carbon dioxide in the cans as they slowly suffocate, peeping to death as a human foot stomps them down to make room for more chicks.
“Ethical questions are raised when unwanted animals are brought into this world, diminishing our sense of the inherent value of the living creature.” – F. Barbara Orlans, Senior Research Fellow at the Kennedy Institute of Ethics, Georgetown University
Destroying male chicks is an age-old farming practice. At an agribusiness meeting I once met a farmer who described to me the “old-fashioned” method of running over male chicks with a truck. In an article in New Scientist, Ruth Harrison, author of the influential book Animal Machines in 1964, described “the old practice of filling up a dustbin with them and letting them suffocate.”
Market created for killing chicks
Since most ordinances allowing residents to have a few chickens allow hens but no roosters, a market is created for killing 50 percent or more of all chicks born in the hatcheries.
And since hatcheries have no use for them, they may stuff a couple of baby roosters into the box being shipped to the customer along with the pullets (young hens), leaving the buyer to deal with the unexpected roosters.
“I have long anticipated that the wild west climate of backyard chickens would come to the attention of producers and the agencies that promote them.” – Mary Britton Clouse, Chicken Run Rescue email, June 4, 2016
Returning to the rooster in North Carolina who had a home ready for him, why did the shelter kill him? In an email exchange with the sanctuary on May 27, 2016, the shelter manager wrote: “The Veterinary Services division of the NC Department of Agriculture & Consumer Services (NCDA&CS) has requested that shelters test all surrendered and seized poultry for a variety of reportable diseases that could adversely impact the state’s agricultural flocks prior to making them available for placement.”
The manager explained that the NCDA&CS would cover the cost of testing for four reportable poultry diseases (infectious laryngotracheitis, mycoplasma gallisepticum, mycoplasma synoviae, and avian influenza), and that any shelter bird testing positive for one or more of these diseases should be deemed “unsuitable for placement.”
And so it happened that this poor rooster, who tested positive for a mycoplasma synoviae infection, was killed by the shelter on June 3, 2016 instead of receiving the antibiotic treatment the sanctuary would have provided.
The North Carolina Department of Agriculture is not clamping down on animal shelters to protect public health or animal wellbeing. It is acting to protect the economics of the poultry industry. This being so, Mary Britton Clouse, director of Chicken Run Rescue in Minneapolis, wondered in an email correspondence in June: “Will all other random sources of poultry – Craigslist, live markets, poultry swaps, ad infinitum now be tested as well? If not, why not?”
Chicken production breeds chronic disease
The conflict between backyard chickens and the chicken industry is not new. During the first half of the twentieth century, the growing poultry industry consolidated in opposition to people keeping their own small flocks.
In the 1920s, hatcheries with artificial incubators and brooders became widespread. Mother hens no longer sat on their eggs. Poultry husbandry classes and home economics curricula aimed at appealing to farm women gave way to poultry science programs at land grant colleges and universities. These programs, funded by tax revenues funneled through the U.S. Department of Agriculture, continue to this day.
By 1950, most cities and many towns and villages had zoning laws restricting or banning the keeping of poultry, a pattern that facilitated the decline of breeding “fancy” fowl for exhibition in favor of breeding “utility” fowl for commercial food production.
Poultry diseases proliferated with the growing concentration of the confined utility flocks that kept getting larger. As a result, traditional poultry-keeping and poultry shows both came to be viewed as potential disease routes, similar to current claims that chickens kept outdoors spread avian influenza viruses.
Then, as now, under the direction of the U.S. Department of Agriculture and its industrialized counterparts around the world, an increasingly intricate system of voluntary “sanitation,” medication, and mass extermination procedures was established to protect the poultry industry from the disease problems the industry itself created and continues creating.
Kimber Farms in Freemont, California, which in 1934 launched the modern genetics laboratory designed to breed chickens for specific “food” traits, developed a line of vaccines to cope with the chicken diseases that sprang in all directions as a result of genetic hybridization causing immune system defects and the increased crowding, squalor and proximity of flocks to one another in the chicken-producing areas of the United States.
“Most philosophers must have been raised on chicken farms.” – Sherwood Anderson, The Egg
The Egg, by Sherwood Anderson, published in 1920, offers a lugubrious look at an Ohio farm family lured into the new chicken-producing ventures that were being established at the time. Ten years later, they pile their ramshackle belongings into the rickety wagon and head off, “a tiny caravan of hope looking for a new place from which to start on our upward journey through life.”
Father rode on top of the wagon. He was then a bald-headed man of forty-five, a little fat, and from long association with mother and the chickens he had become habitually silent and discouraged. All during our ten years on the chicken farm he had worked as a laborer on neighboring farms and most of the money he had earned had been spent for remedies to cure chicken diseases, on Wilmer’s White Wonder Cholera Cure or Professor Bidlow’s Egg Producer or some other preparations that mother found advertised in the poultry papers. . . . I fell into a half-sleeping, half-waking state and dreamed I was a tiny thing going along the road into a far, beautiful place where there were no chicken farms and where life was a happy, eggless affair.
The storyteller could himself be a chicken longing for a place where there were no chicken farms and where life was a happy, “eggless” affair free of humanity’s relentless schemes.
Backyard flocks blamed for seven disease outbreaks in humans in 2016
“Contact with live poultry in backyard flocks was the likely source of these outbreaks” – CDC Outbreak Reports, June 2, 2016
Between January 4 and May 11, 2016, 324 people were reported infected with Salmonella bacteria in thirty-five states. Birds purchased from feed supply stores, co-ops, and hatcheries were identified as the likely sources of infection. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), “Ill people reported purchasing live poultry to produce eggs, learn about agriculture, have a hobby, enjoy for fun, keep as pets, or to give as Easter gifts. Some of the places ill people reported contact with live poultry include at their home, someone else’s home, work, or school settings.”
The CDC in collaboration with public health, veterinary, and agricultural officials warns that contact with chickens, ducks and other poultry can cause a Salmonella infection “by holding, cuddling, or kissing the birds and by touching things where the bird lives, such as cages or feed and water bowls.”
“What hits me over the head is that the small-time backyard entrepreneurs and hobbyists have all the same disease issues as the bigtime factory farmers.” – Merritt Clifton
What these government agencies don’t readily disclose to the public is the fact that the “backyard” birds sold by Tractor Supply and other farm supply stores harbor many of the same inbred pathologies and debilitating effects of hatchery contamination, filth, stress, long-distance transport and brutal handling linking them to their “factory-farm” counterparts in what is actually a seamless poultry agribusiness.
Misunderstandings are compounded by promotional assurances that chicken-keeping is perfect for people who want “fresh eggs,” “green living,” “sustainability,” or whatever, with minimal investment of time, money or care.
Over the years I’ve spoken to backyard chicken-keepers surprised to learn that a chicken can develop respiratory infections and other ailments requiring veterinary care.
I’ve spoken with people who were told by other people including farmers that cleaning the chicken coop need be done only once a week, or once a year, and that the toxic ammonia fumes released from the decomposing uric acid in the accumulated chicken droppings is good for heating the coop in cold weather.
An example of a small-time chicken operation appears in “The Chicken Project,” published in Orion Magazine in June 2015. Gina Warren, a former vegetarian turned enthusiastic do-it-yourself chicken slaughterer, describes her introduction to “Cody’s free-range, organic” henhouse in Northern California:
WHEN CODY OPENED THE DOOR to the henhouse, the first thing that hit me was the smell. The ammonia stench clogged my throat and nose, and while my eyes didn’t literally water, I wished they would’ve because of how badly they burned. I cannot imagine what a factory farm might smell like, with chickens piled one on top of the other, surrounded by feces, and suffering blindness and ammonia burns from the poorly ventilated air. Which is nothing like Cody’s farm, but good God it reeked.
In fact, Cody’s farm – “two hundred birds, sixty dozen eggs a week. Every now and then he’ll slaughter a batch for meat” – is like a factory farm in all but scale. It’s a factory farm in terms of the attitude of the people running it and as an example of traditional farming practices that make chickens suffer and make them sick.
Chickens kept in filth get sick
Chickens kept in filth, whether in a coop, a live poultry market or an industrialized warehouse, develop respiratory infections and weakened immune systems.
The ammonia in which they are trapped injures their eyes and the mucous membranes of their upper respiratory tract letting bacteria, viruses and protozoa into their lungs, air sacs, and livers. When the ammonia penetrates their bloodstream, it causes immunosuppression with the result that a battalion of disease organisms can colonize and spread through their bodies.
While modern factory farming is responsible for many of the diseases that currently sicken birds and humans alike, it’s important to remember that bird flu, for example, did not originate in Western-style factory farms, but rather crossed from relatively rare outbreaks in wild waterfowl into domestic bird flocks through the crowded poultry farms and open-air markets that spread across Asia.
Historically, such global epidemics as the Asian flu, the Hong Kong flu, and the 1918 flu that killed millions of people during World War I trace back to this part of the world, where every day hundreds of thousands of birds are jostled together in conditions of complete squalor, as for centuries they have always been.
“grete stenche and so evel savour”
But let us not flatter our own history. In England from the 15th century into the 19th century, for example, the City of London sought to restrict the medieval poultry businesses’ “hens, ducks, turkeycocks” and other domestic fowl to certain parts of the city due to the “grete stenche and so evel savour that causeth grete and parlous infectying of the people and long hath done.” (P.E. Jones, The Worshipful Company of Poulters of the City of London: A Short History. London: Oxford University Press.)
Right now in the United States, the “great stench and evil savor” permeate not only the poultry factory farms but the live bird markets which are similarly linked to frequent avian influenza and other disease outbreaks. Each year, New York and New Jersey markets alone sell more than 80 million chickens and other birds brought in from places no one keeps track of. Many of these birds are visibly sick, but while the U.S. Department of Agriculture calls the markets bird flu “time bombs,” the agency refuses to shut them down.
Today, a combination of smalltime chicken-keeping, live poultry markets, industrial poultry farms, cockfighting and related enterprises contribute to the global circulation and proliferation of infectious diseases. People and birds will continue to suffer as long as consumers, producers, governments, the media, and investors like the Bill Gates Foundation, which is currently financing African chicken farming and promoting African KFC, consider the cost to be worth the risk or of no consequence at all.
KAREN DAVIS, PhD is the founder and president of United Poultry Concerns, a nonprofit organization that promotes the compassionate and respectful treatment of domestic fowl including a sanctuary for chickens in Virginia. She is the author of Prisoned Chickens, Poisoned Eggs: An Inside Look at the Modern Poultry Industry, More Than a Meal: The Turkey in History, Myth, Ritual, and Reality, The Holocaust and the Henmaid’s Tale: A Case for Comparing Atrocities, and A Home for Henny, a children’s book.
Karen Davis, PhD, President
United Poultry Concerns
12325 Seaside Road, PO Box 150
Machipongo, VA 23405
Jamaka Petzak says
We “inherited” our flock of around 36 chickens (2 roosters and their ladies) when we bought our former land and home. They had a pretty good life in their own large fenced yard, with plants including huge old junipers which they roosted in at night, a small henhouse, and a large barn stall. When we moved, the surviviing four were adopted by a neighbor whose flock was hens only — and one of our girls rode herd over everyone else, we were told. I miss those chickens!
It is sad and confounding why Bill Gates has turned to more chicken production, when just a couple years ago he was investing heavily in vegan meat and egg alternatives.
Mary Britton Clouse says
Does the focus on the killing of impounded birds who test positive for “reportable diseases” hint at an attempt to silence rescues who bring to light the intelligence and admirable nature of chickens and the inconvenient truths about reproductive disease that kills laying hens and the massacre of male chicks that the industry has known about for decades? As stated in this article, those treatable “reportable” diseases do not represent a threat to human or animal health but instead represent an economic precaution to the industry. Other “random sources” of backyard chickens like Craigslist, poultry swaps, live markets, feed store and hatchery and backyard/classroom hatching projects and commercial poultry transport appear to be given a free pass since they support the same industry view that the birds exist simply to be used and abused. The real threat to that ideology is a more plausible reason why the rescues are being targeted. Heaven forbid the chickens should be granted a status reserved for conventional companion animals.
The industry is now attempting to channel and manage the backyard chicken fad by actually promoting it and providing “instruction.” State Agricultural Extension Services are teaming up with municipal animal control agencies to teach backyard farmers how to do it like the pros. That’s another thing backyard chickens have in common with their factory kin.
Mary Britton Clouse
Karen Davis says
Dear Animals 24-7, thank you for inviting me to write this article.. Mary Britton Clouse’s observations about the motives of the poultry industry and the USDA and its state affiliates in targeting animal shelters and rescues concur with my own. In addition, I believe she is right to point out that the industry and its gov’t allies are co-opting the backyard chicken fad into their own commercial agenda, which includes ensuring that enthusiasts do not bond lovingly with chickens as companion animals but relate to them strictly as “poultry,” “utility fowl” and “production animals.”
Perhaps the strongest block to true empathy and respect for chickens is the Saccharine mixed with the Selfie-ism and Sadism exemplified by “The Chicken Project” piece cited in my article. The combination of the Cloying and the Cruel, Slaughter and Selfie-ism, is very much a part of the Locavore mentality. Michael Pollan, the movement’s guru, repeatedly boasts that he is emotionally and ethically detached from, and that he cheerfully despises, individual chickens, pigs, cows and other farmed animals. He told Smithsonian Magazine a couple of years ago how eager he was to slaughter his own “broiler” chickens because they were too dumb to escape from predators, even though the real reason was that they have been bred to be so heavy and disproportioned for breast muscle that they can barely walk let alone run away. Between “Pollan,” and “Perdue,” chickens are crushed. This is why we must fight relentlessly for these birds against all forms of their exploitation including the “humane” exploitation now being fashionably promoted by so-called animal welfarists. Animals bred to be dead are not “faring well,” regardless of which type of abuser they are at the mercy of.
Karen Davis, United Poultry Concerns http://www.upc-online.org