by Beth Clifton
ANIMALS 24-7 editor Merritt Clifton was confronted at the recent AR 2014 conference in Los Angeles by several pit bull advocates, following a panel discussion of issues in animal control and sheltering with Los Angeles Department of Animal Regulation general manager Brenda Barnette and Best Friends Animal Society cofounder Francis Battista. Clifton, originally scheduled to speak for 15 minutes, had invited Barnette and Battista to participate after No Kill Advocacy Center founder Nathan Winograd withdrew, abandoning an hour-long time slot.
The ensuing discussion with the pit bull advocates was videotaped and posted to YouTube by one of the pit bull advocates, notwithstanding that the outcome scarcely favored pit bull advocacy:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv9-2kC-hHw&feature=share
Related Posts
Stray: A Shelter Veterinarian’s Reflection on Triumph & Tragedy
Bulldogs, bullying & bravado: the heart of pit bull advocacy
Oakland hires former SF animal control chief Rebecca Katz to face Nathan Winograd and pit bull advocates in their lair
Nathan Winograd in perspective
Street dogs in the U.S.? Nathan Winograd has gone barking mad.
End of Debi Day for Nathan Winograd follows Charlottesville debacle
This is simply wonderful, and I hope more people watch it. This group of kids, and their histrionics, really highlight what “pit bull advocacy” is about. I never understood what, exactly, their position was, but they seemed angry that everyone didn’t like their dogs. It appears they want to subsidize low income pit bull ownership and protect pit bull breeders. That is all I got from the exchange. They don’t offer any solution to the crisis of pit bull overpopulation.
Merritt, you mention in the video a research study on idiopathic rage in dogs, and that pit bulls possess a gene which predisposes them to this. Has this study been published yet?
The tentative identification of the gene for a predisposition toward idiopathic rage in dogs has not yet been published to my knowledge, but Alexandra Semyonova discusses the matter further in “The science of how behavior is inherited in aggressive dogs,” http://www.animals24-7.org/2013/07/11/the-science-of-how-behavior-is-inherited-in-aggressive-dogs/.http://www.animals24-7.org/wp-admin/edit-comments.php#comments-form
Agreed! In the link Merritt offered, Semyonova quotes and references another scientist in regards to the breeds differing brain structures. I think we might have included a link to the source material, which is a piece published in a scientific journal. (Too tired to drag it out ATM, but it’s easy to find :))